Chessville
...by Chessplayers, for Chessplayers!
Today is


Site Map

Chessville
logo by
ChessPrints

 

Already
Play the
Colle System?

Learn to Play it Better!

The Moment of Zuke:
Critical Positions and
Pivotal Decisions for
Colle System Players

by David Rudel
author of Zuke 'Em

7 modules written just for Colle System Players.  Over 150 practice problems accompany lessons written in Rudel's crystal-clear, inimitable style

Thematic Lessons
on game-changing
decisions Colle Players
frequently face

Two Free
Excerpts
Available


Advertise
with
Chessville!!

Advertise to
thousands
of chess
fans for
as little
as
$25.

Single insert:
$35
x4 insert:
@ $25 each.



From the
Chessville
Chess Store



 


 


From the
Chessville
Chess Store

 

 

 

 


Russians versus Fischer, 2nd edition
Reviewed by Michael Jeffreys

by Dmitry Plisetsky and Sergey Voronkov

Everyman Chess, 2005

ISBN 1857443802

462 Pages, Hardcover

Figurine Algebraic Notation


From Russia with Love

"The only thing that displeases him in chess is losing.”
–Boris Spassky (pg. 57, Russians versus Fischer)

As far as I am concerned, Bobby Fischer died in 1972.  There, I said it.  After having reached the top of the mountain that year, the messiah of chess decided to quit the game that he single-handedly thrust into the consciousness of the world by playing and defeating Boris Spassky in Reykjavik.

Of course it wasn’t just his unparalleled genius for the game, but his off the board antics that caused the media and public alike to follow his every move.  It was the very fact that he was so unpredictable that made him so fascinating.  It was like watching the great Karl Wallenda up on the high wire; would he pull off another miracle or would he tempt fate once too often?  On a windy day in 1978 the answer came when Wallenda fell to his death before a stunned crowd.

However, the enigmatic Fischer was more like Houdini than Wallenda, as he simply disappeared right at the height of his fame.  Just when chess players thought they were going to have Bobby around defending his crown for the next twenty years, dazzling them with more of his brilliant manipulation of the pieces, he tricked them all.

Yet, such was his impact on our consciousness, that we are still fascinated with him to this day, despite the fact that it is obvious to all but the most blind and deaf, that he now lives in a self-made prison of paranoia, madness, and fear.  And thus is to be pitied, rather than hated or reviled.  This is why I choose to remember the young Fischer; to focus on the great things he did back in the 1950s, ‘60s, and early ‘70s.

Of course, since many of his battles took place against the Russians, it would be of great interest to read what they thought of the enigmatic Fischer.  Well, luckily for us in 1994 Chess World Ltd., a Moscow publisher, put out a small, black, 396-page book called Russians versus Fischer.

Although the paper and overall look of the book (with the crudely drawn Russian and American flags on the cover) were not of the highest quality, the material was so good that it quickly sold out.  This was due to two reasons: first, the book contained over a hundred great games between Fischer and his main Soviet rivals, with each game being a chess lesson unto itself.  Secondly, it also contained transcripts which reveal exactly what the KGB, the Communist Party Central Committee, the USSR Sports Committee and the Soviet Chess Federation, as well as most of the top Soviet GM’s including Botvinnik, Tal, Petrosian, Smyslov, Keres, Geller, Bronstein, and Korchnoi really thought about Fischer, both as a man and as a player.  Clearly this is material that anyone with a love for chess would find interesting, to say the least.

Recognizing a diamond in the rough when they saw it, Everyman Chess bought the rights to the book, completely overhauled it, and released it in 2005 bigger and better than ever.  Not only is the book physically bigger, but it is now a beautiful clothbound hardback with a dust jacket, (as opposed to the first edition, which was bound in cheap looking shiny-plastic-covered cardboard) that features black and white photos of Fischer.  And on the inside, the paper is now of a much higher quality as are the diagrams and font selection, making the book much easier to read.  Additionally, not only are cross-tables given for all of the tournaments Fischer competed in, but new material has been added as well.

In a word, this book has gotten a major overhaul, and what was once a good book is now a great book.  In fact, of all the books written about Fischer, this one may be the best.  First, because it gives you all of the 158 games he played against his contemporary Soviet grandmasters, many which contain anecdotes about the game itself from the player and/or their second.  For example, on page 33, Mikenas says:

When we were relaxing before the tournament, on a fishing trip, Keres and I devised an interesting variation in the Sicilian Defence, involving a queen sacrifice.  So that our success should be celebrated against Fischer, we decided to offer him the bait.  And the ‘fish’ swallowed it.  But it turned out that our work during the trip had been insufficient.  Our evaluation of the entire variation had been wrong: it led only to a draw.  But ‘through inertia’ Keres played for a win… and lost.

Below is the game that Mekenas was talking about, where Keres sacs his queen.  Not only do things not work out as planned, but the Soviet super-GM actually gets checkmated in the middle of the board by the 16 year old Fischer!

Keres,Paul - Fischer,Robert James
Candidates Tournament Bled/Zagreb/Belgrade (1), 07.09.1959

1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 d6 3.d4 cxd4 4.Nxd4 Nf6 5.Nc3 a6 6.Bg5 e6 7.f4 Be7 8.Qf3 Qc7 9.0-0-0 Nbd7 10.Be2 b5 11.Bxf6 Nxf6 12.e5 Bb7 13.exf6 Bxf3 14.Bxf3 Bxf6 15.Bxa8 d5 16.Bxd5 Bxd4 17.Rxd4 exd5 18.Nxd5 Qc5 19.Re1+ Kf8 20.c3 h5 21.f5 Rh6 22.f6 gxf6 23.Nf4 h4 24.Rd8+ Kg7 25.Ree8 Qg1+ 26.Kd2 Qf2+ 27.Ne2 Rg6 28.g3 f5 29.Rg8+ Kf6 30.Rxg6+ fxg6 31.gxh4 Qxh2 32.Rd4 Qh1 33.Kc2 Ke5 34.a4 Qf1 35.Nc1 Qg2+ 36.Kb3 bxa4+ 37.Ka3 Qc2 38.Nd3+ Kf6 39.Nc5 Qc1 40.Rxa4 Qe3 41.Nxa6 f4 42.Rd4 Kf5 43.Nb4 Qe7 44.Kb3 Qxh4 45.Nd3 g5 46.c4 Qg3 47.c5 f3 48.Kc4 f2 49.Nxf2 Qxf2 50.c6 Qxb2 51.Kc5 Qc3+ 52.Kd5 g4 53.Rc4








53...Qe5# 0-1

The book contains a whopping 462 pages, and covers most of the major tournaments Fischer played in:

  • Portoroz Interzonal, 1958
  • Zurich 1959
  • Bled-Zagreb-Belgrade 1959
  • Mar del Plata 1960
  • Buenos Aires 1960
  • Leipzig Olympiad 1960
  • Bled 1961
  • Stockholm Interzonal, 1962
  • Curacao Candidates 1962
  • Varna Olympiad 1962
  • Capablanca Mem., Havana, 1965
  • Piatigorsky Cup, Santa Monica 1966
  • Havana Olympiad 1966
  • Monte Carlo 1967
  • Skopje 1967
  • Sousse 1967
  • Belgrade 1970
  • World Blitz Ch., Herceg Novi 1970
  • Rovinj-Zagreb 1970
  • Buenos Aires 1970
  • Palma de Mallorca Interzonal 1970
  • Candidates Quarter-final (against Taimanov) Vancouver, 1971
  • Candidates Final (against Petrosian) Buenos Aires, 1971
  • World Championship Match (against Spassky) 1972
  • “Return Match” (against Spassky) Sveti Stefan/Belgrade 1992
     

As you can see, there are quite a lot of tournaments and thus many interesting games/stories.  For example, at the Portoroz Interzonal in 1958, even though the 15 year old Fischer would be going up against some of the greatest minds ever to play the game, including Tal, Petrosian, and Bronstein, his legendary self-confidence left little doubt in his mind that he would make it through to the Candidates tournament.  Explaining his strategy with his usual straightforwardness, Fischer said, “I can always catch five ‘small-fry’ in the tournament, whom I’ll easily beat.  As for the rest of the games, I’ll draw them.”  When asked what he will do if he loses one of his games against ‘a big fish,’ he replied, “Well, then I’ll have to catch a sixth ‘small-fry’.”  And sure enough Fischer finished in the top six (sixth place!), which was good enough to qualify for the candidates tournament in Bled/Zagreb/Belgrade the following year.

Of particular interest to most chess players is the answer to the question: “What was Bobby really like?”  Here is what Bronstein had to say upon meeting Fischer for the first time (pg. 20):

I first met Fischer at the tournament in Portoroz.  We sat at the same table: Golombek, Fischer and I.  We had breakfast, lunch and dinner.  And like that for a whole month.  It was interesting for me to observe Fischer, but for a long time I couldn’t understand why this 15-year-old boy played chess so well.  Bobby looked a little frightened, and didn’t associate with us, but only said hello.

But then on one occasion he astonished us.  Golombek and I, old acquaintances, were as usual having a lively chat over a meal.  Fischer would listen, but never utter a word.  And suddenly something in our conversation interested him.  He roused himself and courteously asked Golombek some question.  He had not yet finished the sentence, when I saw a miracle: Fischer’s eyes, which had been as though covered with a misty film, suddenly began to open—exactly like the lens of a camera, and I saw his clear, pure, childishly inquisitive eyes!  But that wasn’t all… Golombek was touched by the approach of the young genius, and he happily and exhaustively answered the question.  “Thanks,” said Bobby, and we immediately saw the same miracle, but in reverse order: Bobby’s eyes again became dim, and were slowly covered by film.  And the picture acquired its initial state: as before we two were chatting animatedly, whereas Fischer was silent.

Of course, this incident did not reveal to me the mystery of his phenomenal play, but I understood the main thing: only that which interested Fischer was interesting to him and then he would switch on his intellect, but he had no time for anything else!

I have italicized this last sentence by Bronstein, because to me this has always been one of the secrets to understanding Fischer.  He only paid attention to, focused upon, and responded to that which interested him.  So later on, after he won the world championship and traditional chess no longer interested him, no amount of money could bring him back to the table.  He just wasn’t interested.  For better or worse, this is how his mind tended to work.

Thankfully, there were quite a few years that ALL Fischer thought about was chess.  Says Kotov (pg. 80): “Fischer’s principal distinguishing characteristic is his boundless love for chess.  He is prepared to play from morning to night, and he cannot be persuaded to accept a quick draw.  It seems at times that he does not want to end a game, even when he is winning.”

And here is what World Champion Petrosian thought of Fischer as a player (pg. 80):  “Fischer’s play produced a good impression, and his success was well deserved.  In the past two years the young grandmaster has changed noticeably.  He has become a versatile player, with a leaning towards positional play.  What is staggering about Fischer is what might be called his chess appetite.  He always plays with pleasure.  This, it seems to me, is one of the reasons for his successes.”

And apparently the feelings of respect the two men had for each other was mutual, as here’s what Fischer thought of Petrosian, according to Kotov (pg. 81): “Bobby thinks particularly highly of Petrosian.  But he was genuinely surprised that Petrosian was so afraid of taking risks.  He felt that if Petrosian were to play more boldly, he would be the strongest player in the world, considering his talent, his ability to evaluate a position, and to calculate variations.”

More praise from Kotov, this time on Fischer’s endgame play (pg. 81): “I have discussed Fischer’s play with Max Euwe and Gideon Stahlberg.  All of us, experienced ‘tournament old-timers’, were surprised by Fischer’s endgame expertise.  When a young player is good at attacking or at combinations, this is understandable, but a faultless endgame technique at the age of 19 is something rare.  I can recall only one other player who at that age was equally skillful at endgames—Vasily Smyslov.”

High praise indeed!  And here is Kotov remarking on Fischer’s boundless belief in himself (pg. 81): “Young Bobby has a great deal of self-confidence… when playing blitz, even in hopeless positions, he keeps repeating in Russian: ‘I’ll get him now!’”

This reminds me of the time I was teaching at an elementary school, and I saw one of my young chess students, a boy about 9 years old, had only his king and few pawns left while his opponent still had almost half his army.  Suddenly, the young boy who was completely lost, looked his opponent right in the face, and with his hands on his hips said in complete seriousness, “Do you give up!?”

Upon hearing this, I couldn’t help but crack a big smile and let out a chuckle.  For although faced with certain defeat, the little boy’s “never-say-die” attitude said a lot about his fighting spirit.
 

The time the Russians played a joke on Fischer

One of my favorite stories in the book is about the time GM Eduard Gufeld played a trick on Fischer. Here is the story (pg. 159):

On the beach, on one occasion, we were showing one another various combinations, problems, and endgame studies. Fischer joined us to take part in this ‘contest.’ He was quick at spotting combinations, and solving problems and studies. Everything was fine until Geller’s second, Grandmaster Eduard Gufeld, suggested that Fischer find how White could win in the following position:








Gufeld: “It occurred to me to play a joke on Fischer, and I arranged with the others that, while he was considering this rather complicated position, all the others would say that the position was a simple one and that they had long ago found the solution.  The solution was by no means obvious: 1. Qf5+ g6 2. Qf6!! And there is no way to avert the threat of 3. Qg7+ Rxg7 4. Nf6# (2…gxh5 3. Qh6#).

’Do you want some prompting,’ the grandmasters asked Bobby caustically.  ‘No, no,’ the American shouted in reply.  ‘I’ll find it myself!’  Imagine: a chess genius couldn’t find a solution that was obvious to everyone around him!  There was horror on Bobby’s features, horror that his reputation of a genius at chess was at that moment being shattered!  And when, a minute later, he found the solution, his face, which had just expressed horror, was lit up by a beaming smile of such infinite happiness that it seemed to me that I was looking at Archimedes’ face as he was exclaiming ‘Eureka!’  I am sure no actor in the world could have conveyed that sequence of horror and joy that we watched on Fischer’s face.

A great story nicely told by the late Gufeld.

The Bottom Line

What can I say?  This is a great book and I have barely scratched the surface of its contents.  There are wonderful photos, games, stories, analysis of Fischer’s openings, tournament cross-tables, as well as a complete index in the back of the book of both the openings that were played as well as the names of all of Fischer’s opponents.

You will be riveted by what the top Russian grandmasters thought of Fischer, both as a man and a player.  Indeed, there are so many great stories in the book that it is tempting to simply skip over the games and read it straight though.  However, my guess is you will find this quite difficult to do.  Why?  Because after reading a story about a particular game, you will want to break out a chess board and immediately start playing through it to see how it all played out.  Additionally, many of the games have great notes to them, and so you will not only be entertained, but will learn a great deal from them as well.

Everyman Chess has done such a great job on this book, that not only am I highly recommending it, but even if you have the first edition, I think you should still go ahead and purchase this new edition.  I say this because there are so many great new improvements and additions, that it is basically a whole new book.  So, do yourself a favor and pick up one of the best chess books ever put out on one of the best players of all time.
 

From the Publisher's website:  Author Biography and Booklist Dmitry Plisetsky and Sergey Voronkov.

 


Index of all Reviews


For more about Bobby Fischer see:

The Bobby Fischer Home Page
http://bobbyfischer.net/

 


The
Chessville
Chess Store

 

Reference
Center

 

The Chessville
 Weekly
The Best Free

Chess
Newsletter
On the Planet!

Subscribe
Today -

It's Free!!

The
Chessville
Weekly
Archives


Discussion
Forum


Chess Links


Chess Rules


Visit the
Chessville
Chess Store

 

 

This site is best viewed with Java-Enabled MS Internet Explorer 6 and Netscape 6 browsers set at 800x600 screen size.

Copyright 2002-2009 Chessville.com unless otherwise noted.